**Last Updated: March 11th, 2026

Executive Summary: Marketing accountability in 2026 requires shifting the conversation from “costs” to “capital investments.” This guide provides senior marketers with the data-backed logic to defend brand spend, justify rising CAC in auction-based environments, and explain the “Dark Social” reality of modern attribution.

Having been in my fair share of low-value meetings regarding the scrutiny on marketing, there are the occasional high-level (unwarranted) syncs that do get me and my fellow senior marketers doubting doubting the value of their output, worse, their ability to do what needs to be done.

The stakeholders in these rooms are generally split into three personality types: the non-chalant (they don’t even want to be in the room), the super inquisitive (generally keen to use marketing to make their team look better), and the pessimist (this is usually your CFO, CEOs or the board of non-execs).

There is always a silver lining with these syncs though, it helps us re-direct output and question the right areas, if it’s leading in the right endpoint. Or, in the words of leadership, it keeps us accountable. It’s easy to get lost in the short-term and long-term value of marketing, especially when your output is fragmented by nature.

One day, your focus is on profit and loss efficiency (P/L), the next you’re managing people’s sporadic emotions, and finally, on a Tuesday, you’re future planning for an uncertain future that might not even happen (assuming you still have the job).

Rest assured, if there was one skill I’ve acquired, having been in these rooms for multiple types of business models and dealing with these personalities, it’s learning how to communicate the value of marketing’s output. More importantly, projecting that you’re more than accountable, that you can OWN and PROTECT your garden.

Starting with…

“We’re spending £X on brand and upper-funnel activity. Why can’t we just put that into direct sales/performance marketing ads?”

Let’s start off with a question you’re guaranteed to get. The friction-point of marketing is that we have to prove value in the short-term, as well as long-term. The rub is that most of your peers will likely focus too much on current KPIs in the moment, as opposed to what the business KPIs will display, say, 8-10 months from now.

To make matters worse, Brand activity (of any kind) is unbelievably difficult to attribute and derive deterministic results from. You spending £750,000 on your next seasonal Connected TV/YouTube campaign is worthless, in the eyes of the beholder – stakeholders could care less about Reach and visibility.

I’ve given a bit of a clue already, but there is a direct correlation between short-term growth (acquisition-based) vs long-term growth (creating awareness and demand). If your stakeholders can’t quite grasp that concept, let’s talk in numbers instead.

Acquisition-based marketing (most likely advertising) can easily saturate demand. Remember, the algorithms are designed to cater to customer attributes (signals) that indicate an intent to buy.

Forecasted numbers in relation to customers looking to buy are only 3%, so unless your revenue is purely derived from repeat customers, you always need to create new demand. In simple terms, 97% of new customers are not in the intent of buying (or burning within your category), which gives you room to make them aware of you and evoke demand, AKA brand activity.

By pushing too aggressively on acquisition/direct-response marketing, expect your CPA/CACs to rise imminently. This is basic maths (at least in my mind).

If there are 100 people in a room I can market to, but only 20 of them are “eventually” going to buy from me – assuming I’ve acquired these customers, I’d be an idiot trying to market and spend more towards the 80% that’s left.

By marketing to this 80% (people who won’t be customers), I’m essentially burning cash > hiking up my blended CPA/CACs, and worse, wasting resources on something intangible.

If your CFO still ain’t satisfied, slap them… I meant to educate them on the following:

Brand Search Volume: By deploying brand activity, you push potential customers to search for you, AKA brand demand. Thankfully, you can even track the incremental number of people searching through tools like Keyword Planner and search term demand with Google Trends.
Lower Blended/Paid CAC: While this write-up isn’t about calculations, brand activity supports lowering your blended/paid CACs. Demand Gen happens way before the Direct Response click, making Brand searches have higher conversion rates by nature – talk about ROI.

“Our Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC) is rising month-on-month. Why should we keep increasing (or sustaining) spending on advertising at this level?”

My first step here is an inclination to educate your whole business on the fact that all digital advertising (and some offline channels) is fundamentally based on an auction model, i.e. prices are dictated by supply and demand. How else does a platform like Google and Meta grow YoY?

In other words, advertising is a competition, and prices increase over time, just like how inflation and capitalism affect the very customers it’s meant to serve. Some of us call this “media price inflation”.

That should solve about 90% of the question, but if you want the 10% that’s left over, read on.

Baselines are truly a gift when it comes to justifying marketing and all of its limbs. I’d start off with understanding your average baseline metrics, as this will cover your bases (especially when your CFO wants to cut advertising budgets). You’d start to speculate how these metrics evolve over time.

  • CPM: This is a basic way to see how much ads cost per 1,000 impressions. It’s very likely during more seasonal periods that your CPM hikes up, which automatically entails your CACs rising. If it’s more expensive to show your ads, it’s more expensive to acquire new customers.
    Blended CAC: Just because your CAC is rising, say £50 to £75 (+50%), don’t be reactive about the increase and start reducing your budgets immediately. First, you want to determine whether the increase is in your blended CAC or paid-only CAC. If it’s blended, see if your brand (or category) demand decreases (via Google Trends/KW Planner), as that’s usually the reason. If it’s paid CAC, read below.
  • Paid CAC (ideally broken down by ad network): It annoys me when agencies (or brands) don’t have a sense of channel synergy and start panicking when blended paid CACs increase. Given the number of variables involved in the end KPI projections, I urge you to break down your CAC by channel > campaign > ad group/set (where relevant) and identify the source of the leaky bucket. From a visual perspective, you always work top-down, whereas your mid-level performance marketers will probably do the opposite, down-top…assuming they can even get a real sense of blended paid CAC and proper attribution is in place!
  • Direct/Organic Uplifts: One of the more annoying things about identifying/justifying your customer acquisition (and revenue growth) efforts is that your direct/organic channels will claim a good proportion of it. The way to combat this so that you can sustain your ad spend, is to see how both direct/organic conversion uplifts actually develop over time; and to use baseline KPIs as a compass i.e. if on average you get 1,000 customers via a direct channel, if this goes to 1,500 (+50%) the following month, what variables has paid media done to get to this? Did we increase the budget the month prior? Did we go more aggressive with retargetting campaigns? Did we have a different creative messaging/approach? The answer is usually in past efforts.
  • Incremental Reach: First up, Reach is a unique ad impression, and while its direct correlation to acquisition is impossible to quantify deterministically, incremental reach can (to a degree). Incremental reach is an increase in the % of new users you can market to – it’s worth noting that when you saturate an audience already reached, you’ll be paying a premium for it, hence why retargetting campaigns always have higher CPMs. The value of incremental reach is the ability to understand a larger share of potential new customers you’ve gained.
  • A sense of your customer LTV: Understanding your LTV is a difficult metric to calculate and is dynamic depending on the business model you’re in – and very likely, you’d need an analyst or data geek to get you this number in the first place. Once you have your LTV, you can use it as a lever to justify your increased CAC – this is assuming your LTV is higher, of course! An example would be if a cohort of customers gained in Q1/2027 has an average LTV of £300, our increase of CAC from £50 to £100 (+100%) is justified because a) we’re still ROI positive + b) we gained an X% of new customers while at it. Always think ROI beyond the initial point of acquisition, i.e. what’s the real value of this customer within an X number of years.

If that still doesn’t solve your worries about fighting off the ad budget cuts, you might as well propose to stop all advertising and see where the business lands in a few days.

PS. The above sentence is only satire, don’t take it too seriously!

“Can you prove that this specific campaign led to this specific sale?”

While this write-up isn’t about attribution, it’s paramount that your business knows how it works. Attribution, which is how marketing channels claim a conversion, is like explaining rocket science to a 5-year old… especially difficult when the end personnel isn’t interested!

Some facts about attribution in the digital advertising world:

  • It isn’t a deterministic portrayal of the truth. It is only a narrative. Quote me on that.
  • It isn’t linear. A customer’s first touch point with us, all the way to the point of deciding to buy from us, isn’t a step you can 100% determine or qualify, i.e. all customers go through a multi-touch journey. Once people have chips in their brains that can track this end-to-end decision-making process, only then does it become linear…maybe we’ll get there. Hopefully not!
  • Every marketing channel and platform has its own proprietary attribution modelling technology, attribution window, and attribution type (last-click, linear, data-driven, value-based, time-based).

“If we cut your budget by 20% tomorrow, what would actually happen to revenue or customer acquisition?”

Probably the silliest question you’ll get, but my motto is “it’s best to expect the worst and prepare for the best of situations”. Remember to tell your CFO that marketing is a long-term capital investment, not a variable cost/expense.

What’s tricky about the above question is that marketing has a cumulative impact, so your past campaigns could be projecting their value well into the future (rather than now or the short term). So by reducing your marketing budget now (if you’re cornered into doing so), the actual impact isn’t as simple to identify within a short span of time.

I’ve been in instances where anomalies can happen, specifically, where I reduced ad spend across multiple channels for a month and saw our direct/organic actually increase in new customers. And vice versa, where we increased ad spend and saw a decrease in growth organically/direct. This happens more often than not.

To reiterate, this isn’t a write-up on attribution, so I’ll quickly move into how to approach this situation instead. The efficiency approach is, in many ways, a trap. The better way to alleviate marketing budget cuts is to reframe the questions into the following:

“What do we deem as being efficient?”

“What does efficiency actually look like practically?”

“If we reduced marketing budget, what long-term (or hidden) costs would we be sacrificing?”

Each of these questions is a dissertation in itself, but it will, at the very least, help you and the wider business rethink cutting marketing costs, erm… investment.

“A marketing cut is a short-term accounting gain for a long-term structural loss.” – by Unknown

“Why are we spending so much on ‘Content’ and ‘Social’, when we can’t even track its ROI for the business?”

Building on top of the previous points, content marketing is not designed purely for acquisition; you have to see content as an enabler of sales. There are tactics to tie in attribution to content, but that isn’t what this write-up is about.

Before we proceed, I’ll assume that your business is already doing content marketing. Your focus should be on projecting the value of content marketing, whether that’s social media, blogs, thought-leadership pieces on LinkedIn or PR.

We’ve already discussed that a customer’s decision-making process is not linear, and this is more so when we involve the touchpoint of content marketing.

You’ll eventually start hearing marketers talk more about “Dark Social”, which are “invisible” shares and conversations that your customers (and prospects) have in private channels that web/app/product analytics tools cannot track. Think WhatsApp, Slack, Social Media platforms, and content on external websites not trackable from a business KPI perspective (like LinkedIn or publisher sites).

Simply put, these content engagements, whether a content view, content share, a comment or a discussion, are a factor in both enabling customers to buy from you.

In the offline world, we’d call this “word-of-mouth”, in the digital world, we call this “content marketing engagement”. Just because you can’t directly attribute a conversion from a social post doesn’t mean there isn’t any value. The halo effect of other people’s influence on your decision-making is higher than you’d like to admit.

“Our competitor is doing XYZ, shouldn’t we do the same tactic or approach?”

This question is tricky because it’s valid. Marketing is a battlefield, and missing out on the latest tactics, strategies and frameworks can be detrimental to your efforts.
You’d generally be in two situations when you get asked this question: either you weren’t aware of what your competitors are doing, or, hopefully, their approach isn’t something you don’t deem valuable.

First up, empathy for the board/stakeholders, they usually have the FOMO syndrome, and the marketing function is an easy target to put pressure on – when in reality, understanding the competition (and their outputs) should be a company-wide agenda.

I’d tackle this question more subtly. Here are the levers you’d have on your side:

The Differentiation Argument: If growing a business were as easy as copying your competitors, why do you even exist? The counter-argument is that we use marketing as a huge factor in differentiation and being better, and that gets extended onto your tactics/strategies. Triple down on the value of an output that is working for you, that your competitor may not be doing (or is doing badly).

The First-Mover Advantage vs. Late-Comer Tax: If you were completely blindsided by a competitor’s marketing output, my condolences – in this instance, I’d explain the risks of deploying a similar tactic as a late-comer. These could be that your competitors have already grabbed a good portion of the market, your CPM premiums will be higher (= higher CACs). You could also state that you are contemplating a newer, undervalued channel. And finally, that your competitors’ tactics could be an initiative you were being more strategic on (hence the delayed decision-making).

The Internal Capability Problem (Resourcing): This is an easy MOAT to utilise as every company has its own internal structure that may or may not help them execute on certain initiatives. An extreme example of this could be competitor XYZ, which has an in-house content team and thought-leaders in your business category. With this, competitor XYZ can actually use LinkedIn content as a strategic acquisition (or lead-magnet) output – whereas our company’s thought-leaders may not be equipped to deploy the content end-to-end, as we don’t have those internal capabilities. There are 100s more examples; find a grandiose excuse that saves your back, just make sure that it doesn’t sound like an excuse.
Vanity vs. Sanity Syndrome: Just because your competitor is doing a new tactic, doesn’t necessarily mean it’s working. There’s no way to justify copying them if you can’t see the KPIs they’re actually achieving (beyond engagement and traffic count. I believe it’s better to focus on the 3% of marketing output that drives 97% of your results, and not be distracted by the 1,000 other agendas we get bombarded with daily. If you check your internal data, I’m sure the numbers will agree that only a handful of outputs actually get you your desired results.

Author: Jonathan Milanes

Jonathan Milanes is the founder of Proverve (a premium end-to-end advertising consultancy), a multidisciplinary performance marketing coach and consultant and the author of the book Future-proof Marketing.